Top 3 at the shop, off the map five miles out: a South Hills roofer audit
We scanned a South Hills roofing company from 49 spots across its service area. Within two miles of the shop it ranks in the top 3 on Google Maps for nearly every search. Five miles out it never reaches the top 3.
About this audit
The company has served the South Hills for decades. It holds about 70 Google reviews at 4.7 stars, and the reviews read like a roofer people trust. On paper it should own its side of town.
This roofer is not a client. Everything below comes from its public Google listing, its public website, and scans we ran on November 17, 2026. We removed the company name and the names of its competitors.
How the scan works
We place a 7 by 7 grid over the service area, centered on the shop. The grid reaches five miles in each direction, with about 1.7 miles between points. At each of the 49 points we run the search the way a homeowner standing there would. The number in each square is where the company shows up in the map results.
We ran three searches: "roofer," "roof repair," and "roof replacement."
Top 3 at 13 of 49 points. The shop sits at the center square.
Top 3 at 9 of 49 points. Outside the top 20 at 15 points.
Top 3 at 9 of 49 points. Outside the top 20 at 12 points.
What the grids show
Close to the shop, the listing wins
For "roofer," the company ranks in the top 3 at all nine points within about 1.7 miles of the shop. For "roof repair" it holds seven of those nine. For "roof replacement" it holds six, including a number 1 at the shop itself.
By three miles, most of the top 3 spots are gone
The next ring out has 16 points, about 3.3 miles from the shop. The company holds a top 3 spot at four of them for "roofer," two for "roof repair," and three for "roof replacement."
At five miles, the company is off the short list
The outer ring has 24 points. The company ranks in the top 3 at none of them on any of the three searches. Along the north edge of the grid, toward the city, it falls outside the top 20 at all seven points on all three searches. A homeowner there would scroll past 20 other roofers before finding it.
One competitor holds half the grid
A roofing company about two miles away, with more than 1,000 Google reviews, leads all three scans. Here is the share of the 49 points where each company ranks in the top 3.
| Search | This roofer | Map leader | Roofers competing |
|---|---|---|---|
| roofer | 27% | 33% | 102 |
| roof repair | 18% | 49% | 147 |
| roof replacement | 18% | 45% | 127 |
On the broad search the two companies sit close together. On the two searches tied to a specific job, the leader shows up in the top 3 more than twice as often.
Reviews explain part of the gap
More than 1,000 reviews against about 70 is a wide margin, and review count matters on Google Maps. It is also only part of the story. On the "roofer" scan, two companies with about 20 reviews each rank in the top 3 at seven points apiece. Smaller profiles still win ground where the listing matches the search and the business sits close to the searcher.
What we found on the listing and the website
- Primary category: correct. The listing leads with Roofing contractor.
- Secondary categories: off target. The listing carries five more categories. Three of them describe businesses this company is not, including a home inspector and a supply store.
- A second listing exists. We found another Google listing with nearly the same name and the same phone number, in a different town, with zero reviews and a different website address. Two listings for one business split the signals Google reads and send some callers to the weaker one.
- The town name does not match. The website places the shop in one town. The Google listing places the same street address in the town next door.
- Ten photos. For a company with decades of finished roofs, the listing shows ten.
- Reviews arrive slowly. The newest review was four days old. The one before it was two months old. Neither showed a reply from the owner.
- The reviews describe repair work, and repair is the weakest scan. Customers write in detail about leaks found and fixed. Yet "roof repair" is where the company trails the leader by the widest margin.
- The website has service pages and no town pages. Each of six services has its own page. None of the towns the company serves has one.
- Loose ends on the website. One customer testimonial still holds placeholder text. The Facebook link leads to Facebook's home page. The page description shown in search results is a slogan.
What we would fix first
In order, starting with the fastest work:
- Resolve the second listing, and make the name, address, and phone number match everywhere they appear.
- Cut the categories down to the work the company does and wants more of.
- Add job photos every month and ask for a review after every finished job. Reply to each one.
- Give Google proof of work in the towns three to five miles out, on the listing and on the website.
- Rescan in 30 days with the same grid and the same three searches.
Rankings depend partly on things nobody controls, including what competitors do and Google's own updates. The rescan shows whether the changes moved the numbers.
Why this matters for a roofer
This pattern is common. A roofer ranks well near the shop, sees the listing at the top from the office, and assumes the whole service area looks the same. The jobs five miles away go to whoever shows up there.
To see your own grid, ask for a free audit. We run the same scan for your company and send the findings by email. For more on our roofing service, see Google Maps SEO for Pittsburgh roofing companies.